Who Benefits When Nigeria Mines Its Critical Minerals?
Nigeria's mining law requires companies to sign Community Development Agreements before they dig. ETA Fellow Etareri Dekpe argues that a signature proves compliance, not fairness, and that who negotiates, who is informed and who controls benefits, especially women, decides whether communities gain.

Executive Summary
Nigeria's critical-minerals expansion raises an immediate governance question: can legally required Community Development Agreements (CDAs) turn mineral development into fair, enforceable and locally accountable benefits for affected people? Section 116 of the Nigerian Minerals and Mining Act 2007 requires mining titleholders to conclude a CDA with host communities before development begins. This analysis argues that the regime can permit formal compliance without guaranteeing real participation, equitable benefit-sharing within communities or enforceable delivery, because the legal category of "community" can conceal unequal power over who negotiates, who receives information and who controls benefits. Women's participation is treated as the test of whether the mechanism works. The paper proposes six targeted reforms, from a representation standard and accessible information to a public CDA register, independent monitoring and safe grievance routes.
Key Findings
Section 116 of the Nigerian Minerals and Mining Act 2007 requires mining titleholders to conclude a CDA with host communities before development begins.
NEITI reported ₦401.87 billion in solid-minerals receipts and 2,833 licences issued in 2023.
Sector revenue and activity do not show whether affected communities received fair benefits or whether commitments were delivered.
A signed CDA does not show that affected people understood its terms, influenced its content or can secure delivery.
Treating "the community" as a single beneficiary can conceal unequal control over representation, information and benefits.
A numerical quota for women's representation is useful but does not by itself give women influence over decisions.
A public, project-level CDA register with independent monitoring would let communities trace commitments and challenge non-delivery.
Nigeria's mining sector is growing. In 2023, the Nigeria Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative reported ₦401.87 billion in government receipts from solid minerals, 2,833 licences issued and about 95 million tonnes of production. As global demand rises for the minerals used in batteries, renewable energy and electricity networks, more investment is likely to follow.
Those numbers show activity. Etareri Dekpe's Signature Analysis asks what they cannot show: whether the people living where minerals are dug receive fair benefits, whether commitments made to them are kept, and whether women have any say in the decisions.
A legal promise to communities
Nigeria already has a mechanism for that question. Section 116 of the Nigerian Minerals and Mining Act 2007 requires holders of mining, small-scale mining and quarry leases to conclude a Community Development Agreement (CDA) with host communities before development begins. Regulations from 2011 and 2023 guidelines set out how CDAs should be negotiated, written, monitored and reviewed.
Dekpe, an environmental and gender specialist and ETA Fellow, does not dispute the value of the requirement. Her argument is that a signed agreement proves compliance, not fairness. It does not show that affected people understood the terms, shaped the content, shared in the benefits or can secure delivery when promises are broken.
The problem with "the community"
The heart of the analysis is a single idea. The law treats the host community as one beneficiary. That can be necessary for community development, but it can also hide unequal power within the community: who chose the negotiators, whose views shaped the agreement, who received information, who controls the funds and who can challenge an unfair decision.
The paper traces the process step by step, from the granting of a mining right through the identification of the host community, the selection of representatives, negotiation and the specification of benefits, to disclosure, monitoring, breach and remedy. At each step, it shows how the process can fail. Some affected groups may be overlooked. Representation can be captured by local elites. Communities may sign without accessible information or independent advice. Broad community projects can conceal unequal access to benefits, and agreements that are never published cannot be checked.
Women as the test
Dekpe treats women's participation as the test of whether the CDA mechanism works, not as a separate social theme. Women can bear mining's losses through disrupted farming, water insecurity, unpaid care work and displacement, while being underrepresented in mining data and local decisions.
A quota for women's representation helps, the paper argues, but a body can meet a quota while real authority sits elsewhere. Meaningful participation needs transparent selection, access to information, documented deliberation, feedback to the people represented, protection against retaliation and a route to challenge decisions.
The same logic applies to money. Government revenue is not community benefit, community benefit is not household benefit, and household benefit does not automatically reach women. A credible CDA should specify commitments, budgets, delivery dates, responsible parties, beneficiary criteria and complaint routes.
Six targeted reforms
The paper's reform package follows from that diagnosis. The Federal Ministry of Solid Minerals Development should set a representation standard, including at least 40 percent representation of either sex on negotiating and monitoring bodies. Titleholders should provide accessible information before negotiation. Benefit schedules should be costed and report outcomes by sex where lawful and feasible. Agreements and implementation reports should be published in a project-level register. Independent monitoring should carry real consequences for non-delivery. And communities need safe, confidential channels to complain about exclusion, capture or retaliation.
Critical-minerals expansion makes the reform urgent. If weak practices are locked in as investment accelerates, later growth may deepen conflict and exclusion. A signed CDA, Dekpe concludes, should mark the beginning of an enforceable relationship, not the end of compliance.
The full analysis, including the CDA accountability chain, three tables and the reform package by responsible institution, is available to download.
Publication Documents & Downloads
ETA_Policy_Analysis_Dekpe_Critical_Minerals_CDA.pdf
Suggested Citation
Dekpe, E. (2026). Reforming Critical Minerals Governance in Nigeria: Community Development Agreements, Gendered Representation and Equitable Benefit-Sharing. ETA Fellows Programme Signature Analysis. Abuja: Energy Transition Africa.
